My Shubh NiveshHome

Home › Learning Corner › Investing

₹18.6 lakh or ₹11.6 lakh? SIP or lumpsum: which suits your money

By the My Shubh Nivesh team · 5 min read ·

Share
Email
Chart: The same ₹6 lakh over 10 years, invested at once or ₹5,000 a month₹18.6 L₹6 lakh invested at once, after 10 years (illustrative)
Quick answer

In our example, ₹6 lakh invested at once could grow to about ₹18.6 lakh in 10 years at an assumed 12% a year, while ₹5,000 a month (the same ₹6 lakh in total) could reach about ₹11.6 lakh. The lumpsum looks better because all of it is invested from day one, but it also carries the risk of investing just before a fall. Most families earn monthly, so a SIP fits their income; a lumpsum suits money you already have and will not need for many years.

It is one of the questions we hear most often: “Should I invest it all at once, or through a SIP?” The honest answer is that it depends less on the market and more on where your money comes from and when you will need it. Here is a simple way to think about it, with real numbers.

The same ₹6 lakh, two ways

Take two investors. The first has ₹6 lakh in hand and invests it all today. The second invests ₹5,000 a month through a SIP for 10 years, which also adds up to ₹6 lakh. Both leave the money invested for 10 years.

Illustrative example from our Lumpsum and SIP calculators, at an assumed 12% a year
LumpsumSIP
How it is invested₹6 lakh on day one₹5,000 a month for 10 years
Total invested₹6 lakh₹6 lakh
Illustrative value after 10 years₹18.6 lakh₹11.6 lakh

Illustrative, not guaranteed. The Lumpsum calculator compounds yearly; the SIP calculator assumes each instalment is paid at the start of the month. Real returns vary from year to year and may be lower.

At first glance the lumpsum wins easily. But look at why: the whole ₹6 lakh is invested from the first day, while the SIP’s last instalments are invested for only a few months. In a calculator where returns are a smooth 12% every single year, money invested earlier will always grow more.

The same holds at other rates. At an assumed 10% a year the figures would be about ₹15.6 lakh and ₹10.3 lakh; at 8%, about ₹13 lakh and ₹9.2 lakh.

Why the bigger number is not the whole story

Real markets do not move in a straight line. Some years are strong, some are flat and some fall sharply. That changes the picture in three ways:

A lumpsum is a good use of money you already have. A SIP is a good use of money you are still earning. Many families need both.

When each one tends to fit

A SIP usually suits you if

A lumpsum can suit you if

The middle path for a large amount

If you have a large sum but feel uneasy putting it all in at once, it does not have to be one or the other. Many investors keep the money in a low-risk fund and move a fixed amount into their long-term investment every month for 6 to 12 months. This is called a Systematic Transfer Plan (STP). It spreads out the timing, much like a SIP, while the money waiting to be moved stays invested.

And before any of this, make sure your emergency fund is in place and your family has adequate health and term cover. Money you may need next year should not be in a long-term investment at all.

Try your own numbers

Open the Lumpsum calculator to see what an amount you already have could grow to, then compare it with a monthly SIP in the SIP calculator. If you have a lumpsum and want to talk through how to invest it, take our Quick Scan or send us a message on WhatsApp.

Try your own numbers

The examples above use assumptions. Your family’s figures will be different.

Found this useful? Share it with family and friends:
Email

This article is general information for education, not a recommendation to buy or sell any product. Figures are illustrative and not guaranteed; they depend on the assumptions shown. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully. Past performance is not indicative of future returns.

More from the Learning Corner